Back to Sages

ר' אלעזר בן פרטא

ר' אלעזר בן פרטא

Entry 505 • Seder Tannaim v'Amoraim

Rabbi Eleazar ben Parta, a) [in the Mishnah Gittin (3:2), Taanit (3:9)]. His sons were Rabbi Parta and Rabbi Shimon [(see there)]. He engaged in Torah and acts of kindness and was apprehended along with his friend Rabbi Chananiah ben Teradyon, and Eliyahu saved them. They brought false accusations against him and asked him why he did not go to the house of Abidan, and he replied that he was an elder and did not want to be trampled by their feet, as stated in the first chapter of Avodah Zarah [(17b).

And see Shabbat (116a). It was said in a hint to flee, they asked Yaakov, Moshe, and David, may peace be upon them, who fled, (Rabbah in Bamidbar, chapter 23)].

Seder_HaDorot,_Tanaim_and_Amoraim.505:1

(b) Rabbi Elazar HaModai was his teacher, as stated in Sanhedrin, chapter 23 [(22a), and in the chapter of the oath of testimony and in Jerusalem Talmud, chapter 1 of Megillah, halacha 11, it is said in the name of Rabbi Elazar HaModai]. The genealogy is written [in the glosses of the Rema to the book Yesod Olam] that Rabbi Elazar ben Parta was a colleague of Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, and afterwards it is written that he was a colleague of Rabbi.

Both cannot be correct; one who said in the name of Rabbi Elazar HaModai that he was his teacher, and Rabbi Elazar HaModai was a student of Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai. And even according to the opinion of the gloss in the genealogy that Rabbi Elazar HaModai was a colleague of Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, it will ultimately not be possible for Rabbi Elazar ben Parta to be a colleague of Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, and it is obvious that he cannot be a colleague of Rabbi who lived a long time after Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai.

We also find that Rabbi Shimon ben Elazar was a colleague of Rabbi, and Rabbi Elazar ben Parta said in his name. It appears that both were correct according to what I will write below, that there was another Rabbi Elazar ben Parta, the grandson of Rabbi Elazar ben Parta, thus it can be said that one was in the days of Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai and one was in the days of Rabbi. Rabbi Shimon ben Elazar, because of Rabbi Elazar ben Parta, who said in the name of Rabbi Elazar HaModai in Sanhedrin (22a).

In the Tosefta at the end of Sukkah, Rabbi Elazar ben Parta and Rabbi Elazar ben Yaakov say, etc. Abba Yossi ben Hanan says, etc. Rabbi Chanania ben Antigonus says, etc. Rabbi Yehuda says, etc.

Seder_HaDorot,_Tanaim_and_Amoraim.505:2

3) [Reuven was reincarnated in the soul of Elazar ben Parta, although he did not agree to the sale of Yosef; nevertheless, they cast him into the pit. And this is what Moshe meant when he said, "Let Reuven live and not die," that he prayed that when he would be reincarnated in Elazar ben Parta, he should be saved (Amek HaMelech, Dalet 39). See also regarding Elazar ben Horcanus, the reincarnation of Reuven.]

Seder_HaDorot,_Tanaim_and_Amoraim.505:3